Analytics, Economics, EU – Baltic States, Financial Services

International Internet Magazine. Baltic States news & analytics Tuesday, 17.11.2026, 21:05

ECB: Baltics may be sucked into a second debt-fuelled economic crisis

Danuta Pavilenene, BC, Vilnius, 10.12.2009.Print version
The Baltic States risk being sucked into a second debt-fuelled economic crisis if their governments fail to impose adequate austerity measures that support their euro pegs, the European Central Bank said. Latvia, Lithuania and Estonia suffered a deeper economic slump than the rest of the European Union because tight euro pegs too early in the convergence cycle led to asset bubbles, the ECB said in a confidential document obtained by Bloomberg News.

The narrow currency bands add to pressure on fiscal policy to ensure the economies aren't prone to imbalances, it said. Absent tighter fiscal measures, "the authorities in the Baltic states may not be able to prevent a renewed emergence of macro-economic imbalances and a repetition of the boom-bust cycle," the ECB said in a document dated Nov. 17 and prepared for a meeting of the EU's economic and finance committee. The three countries this year suffered the deepest recessions in the EU after their 2004 accession to the bloc fuelled borrowing and sent wages up by as much as 85%, leaving their overheated economies vulnerable to the credit vacuum created by the global crisis, writes ELTA/LETA.

 

Their central banks enforce tighter euro pegs than the 15% mandated by the exchange rate mechanism, with Latvia defending a 1% band. "The experience of the Baltic states suggests that, for countries that have opted for pegging tightly their exchange rates, there is a significant risk that relatively low interest rates lead to excessive domestic borrowing and the emergence of asset price bubbles," the ECB said. An ECB press spokesperson who declined to be identified in line with the bank's policy had "no comment" when contacted by telephone yesterday. Since being engulfed by the credit crisis, the Baltic economies have contracted as much as 20% on an annual basis. Latvia's gross domestic product shrank 19% last quarter, Estonia's output fell 15.6% and Lithuania's economy declined 14.2%. The region's "adjustment is much sharper than that in other central and eastern European EU member states that have allowed their exchange rates to fluctuate," the ECB said. "The tight peg of the exchange rate of the Baltics has implied that these countries have lost significantly on competitiveness versus their neighboring countries."

 

Latvia, which is relying on a 7.5 billion euro ($11.1 billion) loan from the European Union and the International Monetary Fund to stay afloat, has pledged to cut its budget deficit by 500 million lats ($1 billion) every year through 2012 to satisfy donor demands. The country joined ERM II in January 2005, though it never applied to switch currencies.

 

Lithuania, which joined ERM in 2004, is targeting budget cuts equivalent to 5% of GDP next year. Lithuania's attempt to join the euro in 2007 was rejected because the country's inflation breached EU caps. Estonia, which entered ERM II the same year as Lithuania and is due to adopt the single currency in 2011, has cut its budget by 9% of GDP this year, sacrificing demand to fulfill convergence criteria. The country had planned to join the euro in January 2007, though it was forced to abandon that target because it didn't fulfill EU inflation criteria. The boom-to-bust fate of the Baltic States has been exacerbated by euro-denominated borrowing since the countries joined the EU more than five years ago. That's obliged central banks to stick more rigorously to their euro pegs or risk leaving households and businesses unable to service their debt.

 

The ECB said the three countries need to improve regulation of their banking systems, which are dominated by Nordic lenders such as Stockholm-based Swedbank AB and SEB AB. Measures should include imposing restrictions on foreign currency lending, the bank said. The countries also need to make their labor markets more competitive, the ECB said. Wage setting should be made more flexible, more resources should be pooled into export-oriented industries and competition in product markets must increase, the bank said.The ECB criticized the bloc's mechanisms for monitoring the progress of ERM states on their way to euro adoption. Tracking methods need to be more country specific with a view to preventing any regional contagion if currency pegs are deemed to be under threat. "Surveillance procedures for countries participating in ERM II have been clearly deficient," the bank said. It is "crucial" to improve surveillance of ERM countries, it said.

 

The bank said ERM central banks should make clear to market participants that unilateral euro pegs don't rule out the option of revaluations or devaluations. "In countries with unilateral pegs or currency boards, it is crucial to communicate transparently to the public that, until the eventual adoption of the euro, exchange rate changes against the euro remain a possibility," the bank said.






Search site