EU – Baltic States, Law and Regulations, Technology
International Internet Magazine. Baltic States news & analytics
Friday, 29.03.2024, 00:01
Freedom to provide services is violated in several EU states
The Directive
2006/123/EC on services in the internal market ("Services
Directive", art. 15) lists a series of requirements imposed on service
providers, among which a company’s legal form, shareholding structures, imposed
tariffs, etc.
These requirements are not strictly prohibited but have been identified by the Court of Justice of the EU as creating obstacles to the single market in services. They can only be maintained in so far as they are a) non-discriminatory, b) justified by an overriding reason relating to the public interest and c) being proportionate, i.e. no less restrictive measure could be used. As part of the transposition of the Services Directive, the EU states were to screen their requirements and assess whether they met this three-step test.
In 2013, a Commission peer review on legal form, shareholding and tariff requirements under the Services Directive concluded that such requirements can only be maintained if they are non-discriminatory, necessary and proportionate, and that the six mentioned EU states imposed unjustified barriers to new entrants in the professional services market.
The peer review accompanied the Commission Communication on evaluating national regulations on access to professions.
Commission’s opinion
European Commissioner for Internal
Market, Industry, Entrepreneurship and SMEs, Elżbieta Bieńkowska underlined that freedom to provide services
had been one of the initial “four basic freedoms” in the single market.
However, there are still barriers in a number of EU
member states preventing companies and individuals from providing their
services freely across the EU. The restrictions could be various, e.g. restrictions
on legal form and shareholding, on professional qualification requirements, or
fixed tariffs.
With the infringement procedure the Commission is “waving a yellow card” to some states; it is sending a “message of opportunity”, the Commissioner added: “a dynamic single market for professional services will lead to a more competitive European economy for the benefit of all”.
Commission’s position
Excessive shareholding requirements,
such as the requirement that the professionals should hold 100% of the voting
rights and capital in a company, or should have its corporate seat in a given
jurisdiction, can make a second establishment or cross-border provision of
services in these member states difficult.
Compulsory minimum tariffs are not necessary in order to ensure high-quality services of either domestic or foreign services providers, whilst depriving consumers of more competitively priced services.
The Commission therefore requests the mentioned EU states to adapt their rules governing such shareholding requirements and prohibitions of multidisciplinary practices (for example, for architects and engineers in Austria Cyprus and Malta, as well as for patent agents in Austria).
In other states, it is required to repeal
minimum compulsory tariffs (e.g. for procuradores in Spain; architects,
engineers and tax advisors in Germany; patent agents in Poland and
veterinarians in Austria).
In Spain, the Commission is also concerned about existing rules declaring certain activities of procuradores incompatible with those of lawyers.
From a letter of formal notice to infringement
A Letter of Formal Notice is a first step in an infringement procedure and constitutes an official request for information. The mentioned member states now have two months to respond to the arguments put forward by the Commission.
Excessive restrictions on professional services in Austria, Germany and Spain were noted in the 2014 Country Specific Recommendations to the EU member states on professional services.
Further information on:
- the June infringement package
decisions, see MEMO/15/5162;
- the general infringement
procedure, see MEMO/12/12
For more information on
infringement procedures, see: http://ec.europa.eu/eu_law/